The beer scene here in New Mexico has really taken off with some of the country’s top ranking breweries, and several of their recent entries in the Great American Beer Festival have earned gold, silver and bronze medals. Notably, Marble Brewery 1 was named Small Brewing Company of the Year — amazing thing for a city like Albuquerque. With so much beer talk and so many beer purchasing options for every night of the week, it’s also motivated many would-be-brewers to try their hand right in their own homes. Shops around town sell a multitude of grain varieties from all over the world and all the tools and necessities one would need to get started. Several of my good friends have picked up this (dare I say it?) important hobby and have made some stunningly good beer, so good I could have sworn they picked up a microbrew 6-pack and did a behind-the-scenes-swap before I could spot them.
It’s interesting to hear my friends talk about beer, because you know what, it sounds exactly like the sort of processes we bakers go through to make a great loaf of bread. Yeast, bacteria, fermentation, sugar & starches, and temperature control: all the things we wrestle and wrangle with to cajole those tall, dark loaves out of the oven. As one of my friends quipped, “fermentation, man, it’s a wonderful thing.” Indeed.
You might have heard somewhere, at some point, that beer is simply “liquid bread”. Well, there is actually a little bit of truth to that statement. German monks adhering to their religious duties at certain times of the year2 would abstain from eating almost all solid foods. One way to “cope” with this restriction was to cook and ferment their bread grains, thereby converting their bread into “liquid bread” to be consumed in copious quantities. Sounds more like a 46 day party than religious atonement.
I digress. As my friends and I chatted on, and I discovered more and more about their process, I found there is actually a fair amount of waste when a batch of beer is made. Grains that are soaked to release starches as food for brewer’s yeast are essentially thrown out after they produce what’s needed, wasting what could be used as a nutritious component to many dishes. More on the process below, but I asked a few of them to save their spent grains for me so I can perform a set of test bakes and determine what taste profile these grains would impart on the resultant bread. In a few words: a very hearty bread. I’ll get back to the taste and flavor later on but that sums it up in a nutshell.
What exactly are “spent grains”?
One of the first steps in brewing beer is to make food for brewer’s yeast to consume and produce alcohol. This step is dubbed “mashing”: hot water is mixed with grains, usually malted barley, which converts the starches in the malted grain to a sugary liquid that will later be used in conjunction with the brewer’s yeast to start fermentation. As fermentation progresses the yeast metabolizes the sugars in the liquid producing alcohols and carbon dioxide, essentially turning this liquid (“wort”) into beer. This is very similar to how our sourdough starters ferment, feeding off the sugars converted from the starches in flour, producing alcohols, acids, and carbon dioxide.
After the sweet, starchy liquid is extracted from mashing the leftover grains, these now, spent grains, are no longer needed. Some breweries will either donate or sell the spent grains to farms for feeding livestock or a variety of other uses. For the home brewer, however, it is usually thrown away or composted.
Instead of just pitching these grains, why not put them to good use, like, in bread.
Preserving Spent Beer Grains
Like other cooked grains I’d imagine these would last probably a week or so in the fridge. My friend’s small batch of beer produced quite a big bag for me to use and I ended up freezing three-quarters of the bag for a later date. I simply wrapped the grains up in several layers of saran wrap and placed them into two nested freezer bags.
Next time I receive a large bag like this I plan to split them up into small bags with a small amount in each, say 250 grams like I used in the recipe below, and then just defrost a bag at a time per my baking requirements.
Prepare the stiff levain – 9:30am
For a description of my stiff starter and levain, see my earlier post on its benefits and how it compares to my typical liquid one. For this bread I decided to use my stiff starter to help confer strength to the highly hydrated final dough.
|50g||Mature stiff starter|
|50g||Giusto’s whole wheat flour|
|50g||Central Milling Organic Arstisan Bakers Craft (malted, unbleached white flour)|
|65g||H2O @ 85ºF|
Keep your stiff levain in a warm area and wait about 5 or so hours until it’s matured enough to leaven your dough. Time to take a walk with the dog, do some chores, or if you’re like me, read some more about sourdough and plan for the next bake.
You can see above just how stiff my levain is, so stiff you almost tear it out of the bowl to lay on top in preparation for mixing. It makes for a bit more work when incorporating the levain, but it does help strengthen up the dough.
Autolyse & Mix – 1:40pm
We will do a one hour autolyse with this dough.
You will want to keep in mind with this recipe that spent grains will still have quite a bit of water contained within, unless whomever gave them to you dried them out. When I received my bag they were still very wet, almost like a porridge. Adjust the hydration of your dough to suit: start with lower hydration, maybe around 700g, and increase in small increments. I ended up here at 800g total water and I could have done with about 20g less in the end, but the crust & crumb didn’t suffer — I got lucky.
Gather the following:
|100g||Giusto’s whole wheat flour||10%|
|50g||Bob’s Red Mill Dark Rye Flour (optional)||5%|
|850g||Central Milling Organic Arstisan Bakers Craft (malted)||85%|
|800g||H2O @ 97ºF||80%|
|20g||Fine sea salt||2%|
|200g||Ripe, stiff levain (amount increased from last time due to cold weather)||20%|
|250g||Spent beer grains||25%|
Perform the following for your autolyse:
- In a thick bowl add all the flour
- Add 750g of your water (the rest is reserved until later when we add in the levain & salt after the autolyse)
- Mix these ingredients by hand until all the dry bits are incorporated
- Cover with wrap and keep near your levain for 1 hour (in my case in the oven to keep warm)
Slap & Fold Mix after your autolyse – 2:40pm
After our one hour autolyse has elapsed, and you’ve done all the research for your next bake, break up the stiff levain on top of the dough and pour on the 20g salt. Pour the remaining warm water on top to help dissolve things and to prepare for mixing.
Lately I’ve eliminated the two-step process of adding levain, mixing, adding salt, and mixing. Now, this doesn’t mean I only do one set of slap and folds, but I haven’t noticed any significant difference if mixing is done first without salt and then with salt. I could conjecture here, though, that adding salt might do some damage to the gluten network while strengthening after so many slap and folds, but I haven’t seen any proof of this.
Slap and fold for about 5-8 minutes until the dough looks smooth and doesn’t stick to the counter. Return dough to the bowl and let rest for just a minute, then proceed to do another slap and fold session for about 5 minutes until the dough again looks smooth and has some strength to it.
We do a fairly intensive set of mixing here to help get things started quickly: we want to build up strength in the dough before we add much more hydration later, in the form of spent grains.
|Final dough temperature:||74ºF (yup, still cold here!)|
Bulk Fermentation – 3:00pm
Transfer your dough to a clear container to be used during bulk fermentation and let rest for the first 30 minutes. After the first 30 minutes has transpired, perform your first set of stretch and folds.
- 4:30pm – Turn Set 1
- 5:00pm – Turn Set 2 – Gently fold in your spent grains after turn set 2
- 6:00pm – Turn Set 3
After your second set of stretch and folds add in your spent grains until well incorporated. No need to brutally mix in the grains, just pour them on top and fold them in gently. Subsequent folds will further incorporate the grains. You might need a small splash of water here to help the grains mix in thoroughly.
I found that my dough only needed 3 sets of stretch and folds thanks to my initial medium development achieved during the two slap and fold sessions. If you find your dough is super slack and not holding shape in your container, continue to do stretch and folds until it feels right to you. I know that’s a nebulous statement, but really it’s hard to give any more description to this — deciding when to divide and shape your dough is one of the hardest things in baking.
Pre-shape – 7:45pm
Gently pour out the dough from your bulk container and divide the dough roughly into two halves. I sometimes misjudge here and have one loaf larger than the other, but c’est la vie. If you’re more of a perfectionist, cut down the middle and lift one side up onto your scale and compare to the other half. Do it quick!
Using almost no flour, spin the dough around with your bench knife in one hand and floured second hand. You want a somewhat tight boule resting on the counter, but no need to over tighten here. We’ll let these two rounds rest for 20 minutes until they spread out a bit and relax, this way we can do our final shaping with much more pliable dough.
Shape + Proof – 8:05, Then in Fridge at 10:40pm
It was starting to get into the darker parts of night at this point for me, but it wasn’t quite time to rest — we’ve got dough to shape. Shape each resting dough to your liking3 and place them into flour-dusted bannetons or kitchen bowls lined with a tea towel. Place these each into a plastic bag and let rest on the counter for 2 hours at room temperature (around 70ºF here). If it’s warmer where you are you can leave out just for 30 minutes to an hour and then into the fridge. We want to get that final proof off to a good start before popping into the fridge as the typical home fridge runs somewhere between 34ºF and 40ºF, whereas we really should be proofing for 12 hours or so closer to mid-40’s.
I always proof my dough in plastic bags in the fridge to prevent a thick “skin” from forming on the outside, inhibiting optimal oven spring.
After this two hour rest on the counter you should have noticed your dough rise just a bit with some air bubbles on top and possibly at the sides. Place your bannetons with wrap into the fridge to proof overnight, we will bake these in the morning.
Score + Bake – around 8:30am
Place your baking stone and Dutch oven in your oven and turn it to 500ºF for a 1 hour pre-heat. After one hour, take one of your bannetons out of the fridge and cut a piece of parchment paper to place on top. Take your peel and then put it on top of those two and quickly invert it so the dough is now resting on the parchment paper which is resting on the peel. If your dough has risen up above your basket’s edge don’t place the peel on top, smashing your dough. You want to be gentle here. You can quickly invert your basket with one hand on the basket and the other on the top of the dough to help it land softly on your parchment paper.
(Evidence of cold temps right above in that photo! My German Shepherd sure doesn’t mind, though)
Score the top of the dough quickly and assertively with whatever your imagination imparts in the morning. Here is where you might say my imagination is lacking given I always just do a crescent slash, well yeah maybe it is but there is just something about the look of that properly shaped batard with the ear reaching up to the sky — I just can’t get past that. Next time I do a boule I’ll spice it up, I swear.
Take out the shallow side of your Dutch oven and drag in your dough. Quickly place the pan back in the oven, cover with the deep side, and bake for 20 minutes at 500ºF. After 20 minutes, turn down the oven to 450ºF and cook covered for an additional 10 minutes. Once this 10 minute period is over, open the oven and take off the deep lid of the Dutch oven (set it next to the other half inside the oven), then cook for an additional 30 minutes or so, until the bread is to your desired doneness.
It’s a wonderful thing to be able to take what some consider excess and transform it into a splendid bread that has a very nutritious slant to it. Since making this natural sourdough with spent beer grains, and sharing with my beer-making-friend, we’ve come to an understanding. A gentleman’s agreement whereby he provides me with his superb beer and spent grains, and I bake him bread with said grains in return. A win-win and perhaps, just perhaps, the beginnings of my sustainable baking business/co-op…
A dark and brooding crust. When you spot it you know you’re in for a hefty piece. Reminds me a bit of rye, somehow. It was brittle no doubt about that, and crunchy in the mouth — wonderful. Because the grains held on to so much water this bread stayed moist inside almost the entire week I was eating it.
Tighter than my country bread, but understandably so given the addition of the sometimes sharp grain husks found within. To be forward, it is a great interior for this type of bread as it makes for the perfect vessel for that winter soup or stew. Heck, even a roast beef sandwich with heavy grain mustard, go all out with it.
A very hearty bake. I mentioned this in the beginning and I wanted to reiterate that here. Spent grains impart a very hefty, wheaty, nutty flavor to the bread — in a good way. After baking this I would hesitate to go any higher on the percentage of grains mixed in as it might overpower the other wheat and slightly-sour flavors in the bread. It almost has a whole wheat flavor to it, even though this was a predominantly white bread.
Hopefully I find some of you out there making this exact same bread, and I’d love to hear your thoughts on your results. Just remember to keep the added grain percentage at, or below, what I’ve used here to start. Additionally, if your spent grain source dries out the grains you’ll have to adjust the hydration of your bread to suit, and conversely, if you obtain grains in a “porridge” like consistency like myself be ginger with your dough hydration to start.
I really think this is going to be one of my staple breads for this year. Well, as long as my friend keeps brewing and providing me with his grains, and I think he will if I keep providing him my bread.
Recipe and method submitted to YeastSpotting.
Support The Perfect LoafInterested in helping to support more posts like this? It requires significant work to develop and test a dough formula, shoot process photos, prepare a writeup, and ultimately answer questions and provide feedback. Click the button below to see a few ways you can help!
Marble is one of my favorite local microbreweries that has been in business here in Albuquerque for a long while now with a strong following.↩
Strict rules for some monks denote that they are not allowed to eat solid food during certain periods of the religious calendar, most notably Lent.↩
I seem to almost always default to shaping a batard, but sometimes a nice rustic boule is what’s called for.↩